Where To Eat
... Where Not To Eat
VOLUME XV No. 171
W E D N E S D A Y
September 11, 2013

Dining and Wining ...
Where To Go ...
Where Not To Go
THE BEST
RESTAURANTS OF HONGKONG ...
AND THE WORST !
Name of Restaurant | L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon | |||
Address of Restaurant | Shop 401, The Landmark, Central, Hongkong | |||
Date of Visit | Friday, August 23, 2013 | |||
Category |
TARGETs Rating |
|||
Service | ||||
First Impression | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Attentiveness to Customers’ Needs | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Flexibility | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Product Expertise of Serving Staff | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Speed of Service | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Cleanliness of Uniform and Serving Staff | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Ambiance | ||||
Lighting | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Music | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
General | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Food | ||||
Presentation | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Taste | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Quantity | Excellent | Acceptable | Poor | |
Wine -- Unknown | ||||
Choice | Extensive | Limited | Unbalanced | |
Cost | Reasonable | Unreasonable | Expensive | |
Storage of Wine | Good | Poor | Unknown | |
Expertise of Sommelier | Excellent | Acceptable | Unknown | |
Total Cost of Meal | ||||
Very Expensive |
Moderately Expensive | Very Reasonably Priced | ||
Name of Executive Manager | Mr Carl Tang | |||
Name of Executive Chef | Mr Olivier Elzer | |||
Comments | ||||
The one, single aspect that separates L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon from most other, fine-dining restaurants is its attention to every last detail of a diner’s experience. It is difficult to imagine how meticulous are the cooks and serving staff in making patrons feel that coming to this restaurant is not just for the food, but also for the experience. For that is what it is like to visit this restaurant, located at The Landmark, Hongkong Island, in the heart of the Central Business District. TARGET (泰達財經) returned to L’Atelier on Friday, August 23, 2013, at 6:30 pm and, as luck would have it, our three-man team was ushered to the same table that this medium occupied on February 23, 2007. What was very apparent was that, on the night of this medium’s visit, the restaurant was packed to its full capacity (standing room, only); and, that most, if not all, of the serving staff had been replaced since this medium’s last visit. But, notwithstanding the fact that, with one exception, European serving staff appeared to be non-existent, the existing serving staff of today is just as attentive as those of old. The first impression that TARGET received on entering the restaurant was one of warmth as our reviewers were ushered to the table that had been reserved, under the non-de-plume of Ms Lee. As silken music wafting sweetly through the restaurant, the menu was studied and, having made selections, this was that which were ordered: First Courses
Scampi Raviolis with Black Truffle and Foie Gras Sauce
Tomato ‘Mille-Feuille’ Layered with Crabmeat, Avocado and
Green Apple
Maine Lobster Salad with Ratte Potato, Avocado, Radish and
Lemon Olive Oil Main Courses
Cod Fish Fillet Marinated in Sake and Mirin with Miso Sauce
Crispy Amadai Fillet with Purple Artichokes and Barigoule
Sauce
Pan Seared Veal Sweetbread Flavoured with Bay Leaves and
Salad Deserts
Cheese Platter
Vanilla Soufflé with Raw Egg
Chocolate Soufflé The Food To begin with, the presentation of all of the dishes was nothing short of spectacular. In respect of the first course, outstanding was the Tomato ‘Mille-Feuille’ – because it, actually, had the appearance of a ‘real’ mille-feuille, a 1,000-leaf, layered cake. As for the taste, it was quite unbelievable with the various flavours, tickling one’s taste buds with every bite. Not to be outdone, completely, the Main
Lobster Salad was par excellence, but its presentation could not
top that of the Tomato ‘Mille-Feuille’. On a plate, there were two generous portions of cod, folded into a leaf that the serving staff could not seem to identify, but which appeared to be the leaf of a coffee plant. The cod fish had been smoked, or so it tasted … and it was delicious. If one enjoys sweetbreads – sweetbread, being the pancreas of a calf – then this restaurant is the place to taste them. If, on the other hand, one has never tasted sweetbreads, then, it is high time to sample this dish. L’Atelier is one of the very few restaurants in Hongkong that has amadai on its menu. This is a fish, also known as a tilefish that, usually, swims in sandy areas, especially near coral reefs. The Japanese, TARGET was told, eat them in great quantities. L’Atelier fries the amadai, scales and all, so that the skin is crispy, leaving the meat of the fish as succulent as can be. The desserts were, all, excellent, with the cheese trolley, topping the list for the conclusion of the meal. It is one of the best cheese trolleys that this medium has seen for some time. For those with a sweet tooth, the soufflés were delicious and the raw egg, located at the base of the vanilla soufflé, was something extraordinary since it had absorbed some of the flavours of the other ingredients, during the baking process. The total cost of the meal for three people was $HK4,250 plus a 10-percent service charge. This price is in keeping with most, fine-dining establishments of the territory, but there are few pretenders to the throne of L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon that can compete to the level that this restaurant has set. The Ambiance Seated at one of the tables, deep in the heart of this restaurant that can accommodate 32 diners (or luncheon patrons), one can view a relatively new addition: A semi-furnished verandah. Instead of looking at a flat roof, as was the case in the past, one can see a little greenery and a few tables and chairs. At the bar area, which can seat 42 patrons, one is somewhat isolated unless one has that special ‘somebody’ alongside. It appeared, on TARGET’s visit, that the bar area is the haunt of the younger set while the tables in the inner sanctum are mostly occupied with the more-mature patrons. But the service, no matter where one is seated, is excellent. On entering the restaurant from the lift, the two hostesses, for the most part, are not particularly friendly, but they are efficient. That is the only negative comment that this medium can make about L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon. |
||||
While TARGET makes every attempt to ensure accuracy of all data published, TARGET cannot be held responsible for any errors and/or omissions.
If readers feel that they would like to voice their opinions about that which they have read in TARGET, please feel free to e-mail your views to editor@targetnewspapers.com. TARGET does not guarantee to publish readers’ views, but reserves the right so to do subject to the laws of libel.

